The Arsenal Gallery, Central Park
Fifth Avenue at 64th Street, Third Floor
Monday–Friday, 9a–5p
ConcertMeister
The Arsenal Gallery, Central Park
Fifth Avenue at 64th Street, Third Floor
Monday–Friday, 9a–5p
Oratorio Society of New York – 11/10/25
Saint Andrew Music Society – Chorale and Orchestra – 11/16/25
A friend of mine is a member of the Theater Development Fund and had two $5 TDF vouchers for the Oratorio Society of New York at Carnegie Hall. Of course I wanted to join her. We heard Fern Hill (1961, arr. 1999), written by John Corigliano and Mass in C Minor, K. 427 (1782–1783) by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart. One of the composers was in the house. Do you want to hazard a guess?
The Corigliano was fairly modern in terms of harmonies. It is a setting of Dylan Thomas’ poem of the same name. As always, understanding the text of choral settings is a little difficult, especially if you’re hearing them for the first time, which I was. Fortunately, the text was included in the Carnegie Hall Playbill, as was the text of the Mass, with which I was much more familiar. I’m not great with estimating numbers, but the Oratorio Society chorus was about 200 strong. An octet of soloists from within the group acquitted themselves quite well, as did the entire group. I glanced through the names, but none caught my eye. Not so when I glanced through the orchestra names. Lo and behold, I knew the organist, Andrew Henderson.
There was also a quartet of soloists for the Mass who also acquitted themselves quite well. The Bass-Baritone had precious little to do, but he did it with aplomb. A day or so after the concert, I emailed Mr. Henderson, who answered with a note about his upcoming concert, and asked if I would be interested in a comp ticket. Yes, indeedy.
The Saint Andrew concert consisted of Vesperae Solenelles de Confessore, K. 339 (1780) by the aforementioned W.A. Mozart and Saint Nicolas Op. 42 (1948) by Benjamin Britten – Introduction; The Birth of Nicolas; Nicolas Devotes Himself to God; He Journeys to Palestine; Nicolas Comes to Myra and Is Chosen Bishop; Nicolas from Prison; Nicolas and the Pickled Boys; His Piety and Marvellous Works; The Death of Nicolas. I enjoyed the Mozart, but I was taken aback by the Britten. First off, there was a third vocal ensemble—the New York City Children’s Chorus – Mary Huff, Artistic Director. Soloists in the work included Saint Nicolas (tenor), The Boy Nicolas (treble), and Three Pickled Boys (trebles). Logistically, the performance was a tour-de-force. Soloists entered from stage right and sang in front of the conductor, who was in front of the orchestra, which was in front of the Chorale vocalists. Confused yet? The Boy Nicolas was the first soloist followed by Saint Nicolas and then the Three Pickled Boys who made their way down from the gallery, where the youthful choristers were seated, and then entered down the center aisle of the sanctuary for their brief shining moments, before exiting to the stage right area and somehow making their way back to the gallery. In a somewhat more modern take, the New York City Children’s Chorus treats trebles equally*—in fact, two of The Pickled Boys were female. The work is essentially a cantata in two parts with a hymn for the choirs and the congregation at the end of the first half and a concluding hymn for the choirs and the congregation to end the work. This was my first time hearing the work and I was mightily impressed. I would love to hear it again sometime. The tenor solo part was written for Peter Pears, which makes perfect sense; Mr. Molomot was well up to the task.
All in all, a great week of listening for me.
ConcertMeister
*My first paid choir gig was as an alto in a choir of Men and Boys. Many choirs maintain that distinction, but female trebles are making inroads.
Au pied du Parnasse
“Hecuba and Polyxena”, a haunting, surreal adaptation inspired by Euripides and the American eugenics movement, follows two women as they navigate grief, survival, and sacrifice. (Their words, not mine.)
From the company’s website – Thank you for attending our presentation of Hecuba and Polyxena by Amanda Andrei as part of New York Classical’s New Visions New Play Development program.
I attended. I enjoyed it. Alas, there was no program (not even a QR code, which would probably have done me no good, anyway). This was a workshop reading performance. There were three unnamed performers playing (I think) five roles. (See no program, no QR code, above.)
There was a reader of stage directions who also provided a few sound effects.
The play took place in two different time frames. The one I remember best was the 1970s, since that part of the narrative focused on abortion (and only the male’s support of it, not the female’s). Also, one female character was a baker and one female character was an archivist. Their bond was that they were both Filipina and confused.
The male playing two characters played the husband of the baker and the doctor of the baker. Oh! The baker was probably an illegal immigrant wanting to have an anchor baby.
The three performers played the five roles very well, using bankers’ boxes and lids as makeshift props (mixing bowls, archived documents, steaming soup (shredded paper, used to good effect), baking trays, etc.) and a folding table that was shifted by the actors from horizontal to vertical a few times.
Would I recommend it? No. Not until it’s workshopped a bit more. Was I glad I went? Sort of. Broadening my horizons can be worthwhile. And I saw this company do a free Shakespeare in the park (Carl Schurz Park) performance earlier this summer that I enjoyed. I'm guessing that's why I'm on their mailing list.
ConcertMeister
Violin Sonata No. 1 in D minor – Élisabeth Jacquet de La Guerre (1665–1729)
[untitled] ~ Presto ~ Adagio ~ Presto ~ Presto ~ Aria ~ Presto
La Ménetou, from Pièces de Clavecin, Second Livre, Ordres 7 – François Couperin (1668–1733)
Three Airs sérieux – Charlotte Françoise de Ménethoud (1679–1745)
E ne fuis qu’un bergère with words by Monsieur de Mesange
Louis fuel attaqué with words by Monsieur Le Président de Montbrun
Plus jeun qu’Alexandre with words by Monsieur de Fieubet
Prélude and Passacaille in A minor – Élisabeth Jacquet de la Guerre
Violin Sonata in A Major, Op. 5, No. 6 – Arcangelo Corelli (1653–1713)
Grave ~ Allegro ~ Allegro ~ Adagio ~ Allegro
The first movement of the violin sonata was slow and gentle, then picked up a little in volume; it seemed like an introduction to the work, though a fairly long introduction. The second movement was bright and jaunty. The third was slower and somber, with the violin playing in its lower register. It led directly (attacca) into the fourth, which went back to jaunty with a calm section that followed and led right into the fifth movement which was bright, if not quite as jaunty as the earlier presto movements. The sixth movement had lines in the violin that actually sounded like singing—duh! it’s an aria—somber and almost plaintive. Just as I wrote the words ‘quite lengthy’ it ended. The final movement was brisk and almost happy, except for being in a minor key.
As announced from the stage, François Couperin was Françoise de Ménethoud’s teacher, and his piece seemed to be written for his young pupil. It was a harpsichord solo that was fairly calm throughout the entire work, and was presented as an introduction to the next three pieces. Mlle. Ménethoud was about eleven years old when she wrote them. If I’m remembering correctly, they were probably meant to be sung—here, the violin acted as voice again. The first had a harpsichord phrase as a brief prelude to the violin being added. It was quite pretty. The second was also pretty while the third was quicker and bright and gave a feeling of being a strophic song.
The fourth work on the program was another harpsichord solo that opened with an introduction leading to a mostly somber dance (minor key again), but there were also flashes of briskness, as well.
After retuning the violin, the first movement of the final sonata was sedate and pleasing—ah, a major key! The second movement had a brief violin opening before the harpsichord joined in. It was bright and upbeat and had a fun ending. The third was also brisk with a feeling of perpetual motion. [PHONE!]* The fourth movement was slower, and the harpsichord had an almost plunking sound, as if it wanted to be a dampened pizzicato. And before the final movement, I saw the harpsichordist make some physical adjustment that restored the keyboard to its usual plinking sound. The movement opened with a solo violin phrase before the harpsichord joined in (just as in the second movement). It was brisk again and fun-sounding. Indeed, a fun ending to a fine concert.
ConcertMeister
* I've been attending this concert series for several years. At every concert, it is announced from the performance area that if you have an electronic device that makes a noise that was never heard in the 15th/16th/17th (depending on that day’s composers) century, please make sure that it does not make that sound for the next 45 or 50 minutes or so. (<--- That is close to verbatim.)
England’s Glory: Country Dances, Songs and Consorts of the Golden Age
Caroline Nicolas ~ treble viol; Charlie Reed & Lisa Terry ~ tenor viol; Patricia Neely & Sarah Stone ~ bass viol; Gene Murrow ~ concertina & recorders; Ruth Cunningham ~ voice, flute & recorders
English Country Dances – Musical Arrangements by Marshall Barron from The Dancing Master, John Playford
Indian Queen (1701) ~ Beggar Boy (1651) ~ Beaux of Oak Hill – Traditional
Fantasia a 6, No. 2 – William Byrd (1540‒1623)
Come Again – John Dowland (1563‒1626)
Fantasia a 6, No. 2 – Orlando Gibbons (1583‒1625)
From Pavans, Galliards, Almains and other short Aeirs – (1599) Anthony Holborne (ca.1550‒1602)
The Cradle ~ The Honie-suckle ~ The Widowes myte
Pavan Passamezzo a 6 – Peter Philips (1560‒1628)
Awake Sweet Love – John Dowland
English Ballads and Country Dances – John Playford
Greensleeves ~ Greensleeves and Yellow Lace (1721); Broom of the Cowdenknows ~ Broom, the Bonny, Bonny Broom (1651); The Joviall Broom Man ~ Jamaica (1670)
What is a viol? At this concert, I learned that it is a viola da gamba, a six-stringed, bowed instrument with frets on the fingerboard; hence, it is in the guitar family, not the cello family, even though it is played vertically, like a cello.
On to the music. First up was a set of three dances. The first was jolly and included the concertina and a recorder. The concertina is a free-reed and bellows instrument similar to, but smaller than, an accordion and plays in the range of the violin. The second dance was slightly subdued and had a flute introduction, then all five viols joined in. The third dance had two recorders, five viols, and it was slightly sprightly.
The Byrd Fantasia seemed strophic and fugue-like, sort of like an instrumental song. The first Dowland piece, Come Again, was very familiar to me, and was scored for viols (two or three, I couldn’t see the hands of some of the viol players) and soprano. Vocal verse, instrumental repeat, second vocal verse, instrumental repeat with a bit of vocals added to round out the piece.
The Gibbons Fantasia had very dense writing for the viols, richly textured, and then had the concertina join in. The Holborne was another set of three dances—a somber, but not a downer, Pavan for four viols and concertina, then an Almain that was jaunty and dance-like in a sedate way, with a recorder added into the mix, while the third was a Galliard that was also jaunty with interesting shifting rhythms.
The Pavan Passamezzo a 6 was essentially several sections that were all tied together by a repetitive bass line. The bass line was played solo before the piece as a demo, but with the richly textured writing for the five viols, I wasn’t as aware of the bass line as I thought I would be.
Awake Sweet Love (Dowland) was scored for soprano and four viols and was sweet and almost simple, though not truly simple.
The last piece looked like six pieces but wasn’t. It was a set of three songs, each in two parts. Each tune was introduced, and then the piece that followed was based on its preceding tune. For instance, Greensleeves was performed by the soprano and a single viol; Greensleeves and Yellow Lace began with concertina with two viols and then the other viols joined in. The same format was followed for the Broom pair of songs, though the first tune was not familiar to me. The final pair started with soprano, concertina and three viols. The second version was tutti—jolly and full bodied, with a recorder added to the fun. It was a great ending to the concert.
ConcertMeister
I hope to add a photo; that may need to wait for my Facebook posts.
Chamber
Guadalupe Peraza ~ director, mezzo-soprano; Sinuhe Padilla-Isunza ~ jarana, voice, percussion & dance; Jae Lee ~ harpsichord; Baba Moussa ~ talking drum; Hsei-Mei Tracy Chang ~ soprano; Papa Classima ~ voice
Les Barricades mystérieuses from Second Livre de pièces de clavecin, Sixième Ordre – François Couperin (1668‒1733)
El Buscapiés – Traditional Mexican, Son Jarocho (Veracruz)
Così mi disprezzate (Aria di passacaglia) – Girolamo Frescobaldi (1583‒1643)
Las poblanas – Traditional, Son Jarocho
Jarabi (Love) – Traditional, West African
Accenti Queruli – Giovanni Felice Sances (ca. 1600–1679)
Zefiro torna e di soavi accenti, SV 251 – Claudio Monteverdi (1567‒1643)
Guacamalla – Traditional, Son Jarocho
This was another Gotham Early Music Scene concert.
First things first, what is a jarana? I won't saddle you down with a lot of technical info, but it's similar to a guitar, with eight strings, and a complicated layout of those strings. What is a talking drum? A West African hourglass-shaped drum that is said to mimic human speech. I did not experience the simulation of human speech. What is Son Jarocho? It is a style of Mexican folk music.
While I enjoyed the concert, the application of the Son Jarocho style of playing to François Couperin, Girolamo Frescobaldi, Giovanni Felice Sances, and Claudio Monteverdi made everything sound a lot like the same thing over and over. Lots of rhythmic strumming, harpsichord present but usually overpowered, and the mezzo-soprano and the male vocalist doing pretty much the same thing over and over. That said, the mezzo-soprano did some operatic-style vocalizing in the Frescobaldi, as did the soprano in the Monteverdi. But since those pieces were often grouped with the folk-style pieces, and some of the folk-style playing was included in the pieces that preceded, the effect was a lot of the same stuff we just heard.
Jarabi (Traditional West African) had a little more energy and the vocalist was quite charismatic. But it ended in the "same stuff" category, even with the addition of two different styles of hand-held drums.
The jarana player also added percussion a few times and added a bit of rhythmic flamenco-style dancing. In Guacamalla, all six of the performers seemed to be enacting a jam session in the Traditional Son Jarocho style. They were then joined by four other instrumentalists (I think I saw a rebec – a round-backed pseudo-violin, and three jarana players – apparently the jarana comes in various sizes). It was a great finale.
I doubt that I would seek this group out again, though. They did what they do; they knew what they were doing; it was all too similar for my taste.
ConcertMeister